EPA Tax Could Hurt Local Livestock Farmers
EPA Tax Could Hurt Local Livestock Farmers Save Email Print
Posted: 5:08 PM Nov 26, 2008
Last Updated: 7:02 PM Nov 26, 2008
Reporter: Rhiana Huckins
Email Address: rhiana@wtvy.com

A | A | A

The Environmental Protection Agency is proposing a tax on livestock that could cause farmers to go out of business.

The plan would require permit fees based on the amount of greenhouse gas emissions that are said to be produced by cows and hogs.

"The best thing we had was that we could feed our people and have a good, safe product for our people to eat, but it’s not that way anymore." Says Don Parmer, a Livestock Farmer.

Parmer has been farming in his family business since he was 5 year old.

He says he's worried the days of livestock agriculture will soon come to an end.

"It concerns me that what I have known all my life is dying before my eyes really and I think people need to be concerned about the food supply in this country," says Parmer

If a proposed tax by the United States Environmental Protection Agency is passed, farmers with large herds would have to pay $175 per dairy cow, $87.50 per head of beef cattle, and $20 for each hog annually.

It would affect any farm or ranch with more than 25 dairy cows, 50 beef cattle or 200 hogs- the EPA says these animals are emitting 100 tons of carbon per year.

Currently there are no taxes on each animal.

"Well, if you are making 150 dollars a head, that is over half of your profit that they are taking on tax. There is a limit on what you can do with what you got," says Parmer

The EPA claims that livestock is responsible for releasing methane into the air which is produced from decaying vegetation, termites, and livestock flatulence.

News 4 tried to contact the EPA for more information, but they did not respond.

Some local experts believe taxing livestock is not the answer.

"If you are going to tax livestock because they are putting gases in the air, what about people that have compost heaps in their backyard with decaying vegetation? You are going to have to stomp out all termites, and eventually, you are going to have to watch out for water vapors in the air, because that is a more potent greenhouse gas," says Oscar Fann, WTVY Chief Meteorologist

Alabama agriculture and industries commissioner Ron Sparks is completely against this proposed tax and is fighting.

"Our farmers have paid enough prices in my opinion, and we need to make sure that the government doesn't wrap one more thing around their neck. It’s crazy," says Commissioner Ron Sparks of The Alabama Agriculture & Industries

Commissioner Sparks is urging the public to speak out before Friday- November 28th when the EPA will be reviewing this change.

You can leave comments online by visiting regulations.gov.

More Stories
REPORT: Cops Kill South Carolina Serial Killer Suspect

Dothan District 1 Candidates Speak Out

The City of Progress Lives up to its Slogan

DEVELOPING STORY: Two dead in possible murder-suicide

Firework causes Dothan bomb scare

Pedestrian struck, killed by Louisville police officer

Combined efforts proves to be success

Weekend drug bust nabs more than 10 Lbs. of marijuana

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: walt Location: elkins,wv on Apr 28, 2009 at 01:15 PM
I am a third generation farmer and have worked on my family's farm since I coiuld walk. The government has held the farmer over the fire long enough, after all "NO FARM, NO FOOD". it is time that the governmernt find their backbone and stand up to these extremeists. If I had my way I would hike taxes on any person making over $1 million/year and stop all the taxes on the small business, this will stop CEO's from screwing over the small business owner. I think that the EPA is just a bunch of city dwellers that have never touched a pitch fork or a scoop shovel. I have Put in many 16-20 hour days just trying to get the corn in. Just last year we lost $30,000 on the corn, and are hoping that the cattle will save us. we usually put out 200 acres and run 150 cattle.It is rediculous that they want our money if they want more they should get it from those that have more.

Posted by: Greg Location: Texas on Mar 6, 2009 at 04:18 PM
These are complete idiots, running the EPA that have never been off the pavement and has never done a hard days work or ever own cattle or other livestock and have no idea what it takes to produce meat or dairy products. I can tell you how to come up with money to fight this GHG problem! Fire the EPA and congressmen and senators and give this money back to the working people that have some common sense!

Posted by: Bob Bockavitch Location: Alabama on Jan 9, 2009 at 08:55 PM
People from the EPA says that farmers are responsible for the impact their production has on animals and the rest of the planet. The EPA would have to tax the Farmers for their livestock taxing them wont help eliminate the greenhouse effect. There are many more substances out there that give off more methane and chemicals that cause global warming than livestock. Barak Obama's cabinet supports this idea of enforcing this. Obama is try to fix the finicial crisis, but he will only be making it worse by hurting the farmers of the whole world who will be losing any where from $200-$200,000 each year for getting taxed on livestock. Us farmers need to step out and put a stop to this discussion of taxing farmers for the gas produced in livestock.

Posted by: E.L.S. Location: Texas on Dec 17, 2008 at 01:26 PM
To the bereaucrats our country has way bigger problems then livestock passing gases. If this is best thing you people can come up with in our offices our country is headed for disaster. What do you think this country was built from? This country isnt being destroyed by our livestock it's being destroyed by the government coming up with these ridiculous ideas. The farmers and ranchers have enough to worry about than someone in our office trying to take more from them. who ever came up with this idea should be ran out of office or where ever they are. This would put every rancher in this country out of there jobs. The government is always coming up with ways to hurt our country and take our "so called freedom" away and help the other countries that we have to worry about shipping goods into our country. Make alot of sense. I don't like to call people stupid but the person that came up with this, well is. Come on people we have to stand up for our rights and country. enough is enough!!!

Posted by: Judi Location: wiregrass on Nov 30, 2008 at 03:28 PM
I found some articles about the EPA regulating DUST under the Clean Air Act. DUST! How long will it take for them to rule peanut farming as illegal, and John Deere tractors as contraband? Seriously folks, our rights are being taken away, inch by inch, day by day. If we become dependent upon other countries for our food supplies, then all our freedoms will vanish.

Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 28, 2008 at 07:05 AM
ok what about all of the wild life out in the woods and the zoos and everyone that has pets are they gonna be taxed as well? Can you say our food now comes from overseas. Do you like that beef from china?

Posted by: Richard O. Waters Location: Coffee County on Nov 27, 2008 at 08:49 PM
This is absolutely ludicrous. We must keep our Farmers in business so that we will have food to eat. Please write your congressmen and senators. America-"We The People" better wake up and get rid of these bureaucrats who are completely out of their mind and out of touch with reality. Please help us, stand up and fight so that we and our country will remain "FREE'.

Posted by: Carl Location: Pansey on Nov 27, 2008 at 07:58 PM
Its just another way for Big Brother to bring our country down to the level of third world countries. For some reason they don't understand or don't want to understand, if we can't feed ourselves and become dependant upon other countries our national security becomes vulnerable. And if the truth is know, the money will be in some politicians pocket or sent overseas to help the "poor farmers" in some other country. Give the Farmers a break. In the words of Andy Griffith, "act like you got some smarts".

Posted by: Bootsie Location: Ozark on Nov 27, 2008 at 07:07 PM
Oscar, Scott and Linda among others are correct. We need to call Willie to the rescue again and more prople need to take action. Meat will be outragiosly priced if we can get it at all. They ban it all let other countries use it and then ship it back. Leave our farmers alone for healthy foods. Start bottling YOUR methane gas you idiots in office

Posted by: Dee Location: Dothan on Nov 27, 2008 at 10:43 AM
This is ridiculous. It will make imported meats, which do not have such a tax, more competitive. Just another industry shuttled out of the US. We NEED our US farmers, food is expensive enuf!!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 27, 2008 at 09:45 AM
Write a letter (e-mail) to your senators and congressman today. This legislation is nothing but political influence brought on by Green Fanatics.

Posted by: Scott Location: Houston Co. on Nov 27, 2008 at 09:35 AM
The need to tax cows and hogs because of the methane gas pollution is wrong. The EPA in their infinite wisdom needs to be finding a way to use this gas to help the energy crisis. Are HUMANS going to be taxed for their methane gas pollution?

Posted by: linda Location: headland on Nov 27, 2008 at 07:01 AM
The people we have elected have lost their minds. The farmer can not afford this! Who do you think feeds us? We have to have farmers to eat! Wake up people, between the tax hikes, rising prices and all the crap taking place, do you want to hand over our country to whoever decides to take over, sounds like between more taxes, defense budget cuts you want America to fall!!!! Wake up and fight for our country, our way of life, our freedom. Keep the American farmer in business>

Posted by: claudia Location: ozark, al on Nov 27, 2008 at 01:15 AM
farmers are already paying a hefty tax on feed for their animals & now our government wants to increase their tax?? this is unbelievable - I am sure the EPA is aware of the consequences of this action. The consumers will pay in the long run as always.

Posted by: Cary Location: Hartford on Nov 26, 2008 at 11:27 PM
My husband has been raising cattle for almost 50 years and this is absolutely ridiculous. The government is once again trying to run our farmers out of business and our food will be produced out of this country without any regulations. Why not tax people too - they also produce methane gas! If you care, comment to the EPA! Go to this website and click on "comment": http://www.regulations.gov/fdmspublic/component/main?main=DocumentDetail&o=09000064806a0cfd

Posted by: Mike Location: Coffee Co on Nov 26, 2008 at 09:17 PM
This is just another issue that's devastating to our country. In the past we called such people communists or he/she could be a vegetarian idiot.People, we need to shoot this one down. They're sneaking up on us.

Posted by: Rochelle Location: Houston County on Nov 26, 2008 at 08:40 PM
This is ludicrous!I guess next 'WE' will be taxed for flatulence. I have a compost pile,once considered recycling. Will I now be taxed for emmisions? This is just another sad exampel of bureaucrat BS! Oh look they are polluting. HA! Is the economy not in bad enough shape? Now are bureaucrats want us all to be vegatrians and put thousands of our bread bowl workers out of their livelyhood. What has happened to my America the Beautiful The Land of the Free.The ramifications of this act could go much deeper than our pockets.Ask your meteorologist. We the people have the power we just must take control of it. Help yourself.

Posted by: R.C.S. Location: Cowarts on Nov 26, 2008 at 06:41 PM
This really stinks..We are paying high enough prices for food and our farmers aren't getting anything in return..If they go under who is going to fed our country?

Posted by: karen Location: houston co on Nov 26, 2008 at 06:13 PM
the proposed tax on livestock is crazy!!!!!! there is no way they should tax livestock this is just another way to try to put small business owners out of business!!!! whoever came up with this idea is out of their mind!!!!

Tom West Company Search Listing Virtual Tours
Contests and Promotions
Win a 2010 Camaro!
Join the search for Captain Archie's lost keys.
Protect your family
Hear first when weather warnings are issued.
Be Prepared
Look at our checklist to see if you're ready.
Summer Fun in the Sun
Check out the hottest movies, books & vacation deals.
Jeffers Pet Page
Pet News, Care Tips, Shelters & Contests
Double Dollar Deals
Save 50% from local merchants.
Durden Traffic Cams
Click and see congestion on the Circle